Michiana Adventist Forum

Thoughtful discussions of timely issues for Christians…

• Home
• Discussions
• Give

“Gay: The Uncomfortable Truth” – Nancy Carbonell

Date: October 31, 2009

Speaker: Dr. Nancy Carbonell

Position: Associate Professor of Counseling Psychology, Andrews University

Topic: “Gay: The Uncomfortable Truth”

Venue: Biology Amphitheater

Attendance: 92

Listen/Download

Presentation: Carbonell explained 4 historic paradigms regarding gays (open defiance, an illness, innocent victims, celebrate diversity) and examined the studies by Kinsey (7-point scale, 1940s), Evelyn Hooker (male gays, 1957), the American Psychiatric Association (no longer an illness, 1973), Exodus International (RT or reparative therapy, 1976), NARTH (harmfulness of RT, 1991), various neuroendocrine, genetic, and body odors studies (1990s), Robert Spitzer (failure of homosexual behavior modification, 2001), and the APA Task Force Report (2009). Twelve mental health organizations oppose RT as ineffective & harmful, & homosexual behavior appears in 150 species.

search

• Pages

  • Discussions
    • 2004 Discussions
      • “The Case Against Galileo: Its Implications for the Church Today” – Dick Osborn
      • “The Future of SDA Higher Education” – Andrea Luxton
    • 2005 Discussions
      • “The Adventist Health-care Ministry: Achievements and Challenges” – Allan R. Handysides
      • “The Case for An Adventist Law School” – Margaret McFarland
    • 2006 Discussions
      • “Intelligent Design: Revolutionary Science or Reactionary Religion?” – Ronald Numbers
      • “Seeds of Genocide: Witness to the Genocide in Rwanda ” – Carl Wilkin
      • “The Fat Lady Rides Again: Thoughts on the Current General Conference” – George Knight
    • 2007 Discussions
      • “The Christianization of the Sabbath in Colossians” – Harold Weiss
    • 2008 Discussions
      • “Adventists & Creation: A Way Forward?” – Thomas Goodwin
      • “A Mirror of Adventism? Seeking a Sanctuary: Seventh-day Adventism and the American Dream”
    • 2009 Discussions
      • “Academic Freedom and Accreditation on Faith-Based Campuses” – Richard Osborn
      • “Attitudes Towards Intimate Partner Violence Among Seventh-day Adventists: An Interplay of Sex and Religion” – Julia Pickett
      • “Gay: The Uncomfortable Truth” – Nancy Carbonell
    • 2010 Discussions
      • From Birding to Conservation: Adventists’ Engagement with Nature – James Hayward
    • 2011 Discussions
      • “The Lost World of Genesis 1: Ancient Cosmology and the Origins Debate” – John Walton
      • “We Have Seen His Glory: Women in Ministry, Adventism in a Chinese Context” – Rebekah Liu
      • Archaeology and Biblical Accuracy: A Look at Minimalist, Maximalist and Adventist Views – Randall Younker
      • Genesis and Beyond: Reports from the Chicago Adventist Forum – Panel
      • The Promise of Peace: Dare to Live the Advent Hope Toward a Post-Conventional Adventism -Charles Scriven
      • “Adventist Higher Education in the U.S.: Which School Will Fail Next?” – Michael Scofield
    • 2012 Discussions
      • Checking the Political Pulse of the University: Findings from the 2012 SDA Religion and Social Issues Survey – Curtis Vanderwaal
      • CognitiveGenesis: The Impact of Adventist K-12 Schools on Students – Jerry Thayer
      • E Pluribus Unum: For Us? For the gods? For Both? – John Jones
      • Inspiration: Manuscripts, Mistakes, and Choosing a Version – Larry Richards
      • Reinventing the Church for the Twenty-First Century – Gary Hamel
      • Thirty-Four Years Inside Seventh-day Adventist Publishing—A Retrospective – Richard Coffen
      • Why Adventist Healthcare Still Matters – James Londis
      • “Is Everyone in Adventist Education a Minister? Reflections on a Recent U.S. Supreme Court Decision” – Brent Geraty
    • 2013 Discussions
      • “The Religious Roots of the First Amendment: Dissenting Protestants and the Separation of Church and State” – Nicholas Miller
      • “Governing the Global Commons: International Environmental Law” – Kevin Doran
      • Creation in Scripture – Herold Weiss
      • General Conference Policy in Relation to the Ordination of Women – Gary Patterson
      • Why Care for Creation: Ten Reasons for Being Earth-keepers – Steven Bouma-Prediger
      • “Ellen White: Daring Liberal and Immovable Conservative” – Alden Thompson
      • “Exclusion and Embrace: Theological Exploration of Identity, Otherness, and Reconciliation” – Ante Jeroncic
    • 2014 Discussions
      • “A. G. Daniells: Lessons in Leadership” – Benjamin McArthur
      • “Angel Bones in Unexpected Places: Songs of My Salvation” – John Berecz
      • “Ellen White Goes Public: The Collaborative Biography Project Ellen Harmon White: American Prophet” – Terrie Dopp Aamodt
      • “The Sacred Theater of Knowing: The Epistemologies of Hamlet on Film” – Monique Pittman
      • “The Theology of Ordination Study Committee: One Member’s Observations and Reflections” – Cheryl Doss
    • 2015 Discussions
      • “Conflict as Catalyst—Is a Lawsuit the Best Option?” – Deborah Berecz
      • “From ‘Ekklesia’ to Something Else: Church Organization and How It Changes over Time” – David Thomas
      • “Prayer and Illness: Evidence-Informed Reflections” – Elizabeth Johnston Taylor
      • “The Millennial Generation and the Adventist Church” – Meredith Jones-Gray
      • “The San Antonio (Texas) General Conference Session: Insights from Andrews University Insiders”
      • “When Loughborough Got It Wrong: An Examination of J. N. Loughborough’s Historical Writings” – Brian E. Strayer
      • “A History of the Seventh-day Adventist Church in China.” – Rebekah Liu
      • “Death Before the Fall: Biblical Literalism and the Problem of Animal Suffering” – Ronald Osborn; Robert Johnston; James Hayward
      • “The Psychology of a Peculiar People: Studies of Adventist Sabbath-keeping and Other Distinctive Doctrines” – Karl Bailey
    • 2016 Discussions
      • The Adventist Peace Fellowship (APF) – Jeff Boyd
      • Toward an Understanding of Religious Extremism – Rachel Williams-Smith
      • Welcome to the Anthropocene: The Earth in Human Hands – Oystein S. Labianca
      • Where Do My Donations Go? A Conversation on SDA Church Financial Structure – Ann Gibson
      • “Adventist Higher Education: A Few Things to Keep in Mind” – Niels-Erik Andreasen
      • “Adventist Religion & Public Issues Survey” (Advertised as “How Will Adventists Vote?”) – John T. Gavin, William W. Ellis, Curtis J. VanderWaal
      • “Studying the Book of Life: Adventism and the Need to Go Beyond a ‘Blueprint’ Approach to Theology” – Manuela Casti Yeagley
      • “The Place of Scripture in the Founding of the United States” – Mark A. Noll
      • “The Suzy Principle: Why We Talk Too Much and Do Too Little” – Loren Seibold
      • “What Can We Learn from Gravitational Waves?” – Tiffany Summerscales
    • 2017 Discussions
      • Breaking Barriers in Food Equity: A Mobile Farmers Market – Garth Woodruff
      • Contemporary Adventist Music: Facing the Challenge – Adriana Perera
      • Contemporary Adventist Music: Facing the Challenge – Adriana Perera
      • Religious Freedom & Public Morality: Church-State Issues in America Today
      • The Nexus of Income, Nutrition, and Health: Breaking Barriers in Food Equity: Are We Paying a High Price? – Sherine Brown-Fraser
      • The Story of Steps to Christ: The Compilation, Sources, and Setting of the Book – Denis Fortin
      • What Is to be Done with Difficult Texts of Scripture? – Herold Weiss
    • 2018 Discussions
      • Paul among the Ecologists: Romans for the 21st Century
      • Time to Speak Out – William Johnsson
    • 2022 Discussions
      • Thoughts on Lifelong Engagement with Adventist Education – Niels-Erik Andreasen
    • 2023 Discussions
      • A History of Adventist Lifestyles – Part 1 – Bryan Strayer
      • A History of Adventist Lifestyles – Part 2 – Bryan Strayer
  • Give

• Feeds

• Full
• Comments